Score Big at Bodnar’s: Don’t Miss the April 24th Sports Memorabilia Auction

Sports collectors, mark your calendars! On April 24th, Bodnar’s Auction is hosting a premier sports memorabilia auction that brings the legends of the game into your home. Whether you’re passionate about hockey, baseball, or simply chasing that next iconic piece, this event is packed with high-caliber items. With a standout New York Rangers collection on the block, this auction is a must-attend for serious NHL collectors and lifelong fans.

Let’s skate through some of the marquee lots that make this auction one for the books.

🏒 Rangers Royalty on Display

Lot 2 – Mark Messier Signed Stanley Cup Celebration Photo

Few images capture the sheer emotion of a franchise-defining moment like this one. Mark Messier, captain and heart of the 1994 Rangers, is immortalized in this signed 8×10 photograph celebrating the team’s long-awaited Stanley Cup victory. Authenticated by Steiner Sports, the piece is already matted and framed for premium presentation. It’s a centerpiece-worthy tribute to one of the most powerful moments in Rangers—and NHL—history.

View Lot 2

Lot 11 – Wayne Gretzky Signed Rangers 8×10 Photo

While Wayne Gretzky’s legacy stretches across multiple teams, his time with the New York Rangers remains a unique and celebrated chapter. This autographed 8×10 photo, certified by PSA/DNA, showcases “The Great One” in his final NHL home—Madison Square Garden. For Rangers fans and Gretzky collectors alike, this autographed piece captures the grace and legacy of a true icon in one of his last chapters of the sport.

View Lot 11

Lot 82 – New York Rangers Autographed Acrylic Stat Puck Display

Bring home a unique blend of form and fandom with this New York Rangers autographed stat puck display. Housed in a sleek acrylic case, this collectible features signed pucks from Mark Messier and Adam Graves—two Rangers legends who helped define the franchise’s proud history. The Messier puck comes with a COA from Steiner Sports, ensuring top-tier authenticity, while the Graves puck is backed by a 30-day signature guarantee from Bodnar’s themselves.

Perfect for display in an office, fan cave, or memorabilia collection, this set combines clean design with iconic signatures from the Rangers’ glory years. It’s a sharp, affordable way to commemorate some of the franchise’s most beloved players.

View Lot 82

Lot 86A – Wayne Gretzky Signed Limited Edition Lithograph

Own a piece of hockey history with this game-used hockey stick from the early career of Wayne Gretzky during his time with the Edmonton Oilers. This TPM Titan stick, dated 1981, showcases the equipment favored by “The Great One” as he began to make his indelible mark on the NHL.

This stick represents a significant period in Gretzky’s career, capturing the essence of his early days with the Oilers. Whether you’re a dedicated fan of Gretzky, the Oilers, or a collector of game-used NHL memorabilia, this piece offers a tangible connection to the legacy of one of hockey’s greatest players.

View Lot 86A

Lot 86B – Wayne Gretzky Game-Used Autographed Hockey Stick (1993)

Step into the legacy of “The Great One” with this exceptional Wayne Gretzky game-used autographed hockey stick from his tenure with the Los Angeles Kings in 1993. This Easton Pro Balance stick not only bears the marks of in-game action but also features Gretzky’s signature, making it a dual-threat collectible of both historical significance and personal connection.

This is a rare opportunity to own a tangible piece of hockey history, directly linked to one of the sport’s most iconic figures. Whether you’re a dedicated Gretzky enthusiast, a Los Angeles Kings fan, or a collector of game-used NHL memorabilia, this stick embodies the spirit and legacy of Wayne Gretzky’s illustrious career.

View Lot 86B

Lot 87 – Henrik Lundqvist Autographed New York Rangers Jersey (Framed)

Celebrate the legacy of Henrik Lundqvist, one of the most iconic goaltenders in New York Rangers history, with this autographed jersey. Beautifully presented in a shadowbox frame measuring 41″ x 36″, this piece is a standout addition to any hockey memorabilia collection. The signature is authenticated by Steiner Sports, ensuring its legitimacy and value.

View Lot 87

⚾ Beyond the Ice: Legendary Baseball Collectibles

Lot 178 – Lou Gehrig Signed Cut Autograph (Framed)

A truly historic offering: an authenticated Lou Gehrig cut autograph, matted and framed alongside imagery of the Iron Horse himself. With authentication from Beckett, this rare signature connects collectors to the legacy of a baseball giant. An elite-level collectible for fans of Yankees history and classic MLB greatness.

View Lot 178

Lot 191 – Thurman Munson New York Yankees Game-Used Louisville Slugger Bat

Step up to the plate with a remarkable piece of baseball history: a game-used Louisville Slugger bat wielded by the legendary Thurman Munson, esteemed captain and catcher for the New York Yankees. This bat exhibits signs of authentic game use, including a visible crack, offering a tangible connection to Munson’s impactful career on the field.

View Lot 191

Lot 198 – New York Yankees Autographed 1998 World Series Baseball

Celebrate the New York Yankees’ historic 1998 season with this team-signed baseball commemorating their World Series victory. This exceptional piece features autographs from key members of the championship roster, including:​

• Joe Torre​
• Mariano Rivera​
• Derek Jeter​
• Andy Pettitte​
• Bernie Williams​
• Paul O’Neill​
• Tino Martinez​
• Jorge Posada​
• Scott Brosius​
• David Cone​
• David Wells​
• Don Zimmer​
• Joe Girardi​
• Mike Stanton​
• And more​

Each signature has been authenticated and the baseball comes with a Certificate of Authenticity from The Card Attic, ensuring its legitimacy and value.

View Lot 198

Lot 230 – Pair of MLB Rookie Cards: Rickey Henderson & Rod Carew

Enhance your baseball card collection with this duo of iconic MLB rookie cards, featuring:​

Rickey Henderson – 1980 Topps Rookie Card: This card marks the debut of Rickey Henderson, renowned for his unparalleled base-stealing prowess and dynamic leadoff hitting. Henderson’s illustrious career includes multiple All-Star selections and a Hall of Fame induction.​

Rod Carew – 1968 Topps Rookie Card: Commemorating the early days of Rod Carew, this card celebrates the seven-time American League batting champion and 18-time All-Star. Carew’s exceptional hitting skills solidified his place among baseball’s elite, culminating in his Hall of Fame induction.​

Presentation: Both cards are preserved in screw-down cases, ensuring their protection and maintaining their condition for years to come.

View Lot 230

Lot 237 – Derek Jeter Upper Deck SP Premier Prospects Rookie Card #279

Capture a pivotal piece of baseball history with this Derek Jeter Upper Deck SP Premier Prospects Rookie Card #279. This sought-after card marks the debut of Jeter, who would go on to become a legendary figure for the New York Yankees and a first-ballot Hall of Famer.​

Presentation: The card is securely housed in a protective screw-down case, ensuring its preservation and display appeal.

View Lot 237

🏆 Final Whistle: Register to Bid Today!

This April 24th, don’t miss your chance to own a piece of sports history. Whether you’re a Rangers superfan, a lifelong Yankees follower, or just want to secure a few legendary signatures, Bodnar’s Epic Sports Autograph Auction offers something for every type of collector.

Register now to place your bids and preview the full auction catalog. Every item is authenticated, curated, and ready to be a part of your collection.

Don’t just be a fan—own the legacy.