Online Bidding
The Largest Comic Book & Toy Auctions in New Jersey
Sometimes, we can escape reality, even just for a moment, by focusing our attention on movies, music, video games, sports, or anything else we might consider entertainment. Among these methods of escape, reading is the oldest — and most widespread.
One phenomenon that has changed the way that people think about reading includes comic books. As comic books became popularized in the early 20th century, they gave thousands of people of all ages a way to immerse themselves in the excitement of a colorful graphic novel.
Fast forward to the present day — comic books (and the memorabilia inspired by their characters) have garnered massive followings of devoted fans, causing their value to skyrocket. Now, comic book and toy collectors often find themselves sitting on a fortune by doing nothing more than realizing the value of their life-long passion.
Whether you’re a seasoned collector looking to cash in on a lifetime’s worth of fandom or someone seeking the right place to start their collection, Bodnar’s Auction offers one of the largest toy and comic book auctions in the state of New Jersey. As one of the most prominent online toy and comic book auctions, Bodnar’s Auction attracts a wide range of both buyers and sellers from across the country.
Vintage comics and toys are also commonly sold at our online antique auctions, which attract a vast amount of buyers. The collections of toys and comics are sold on our online platform through either traditional or consignment auctions. Consignment auctions are an excellent option for those who are hoping to sell rare or high-value items.
At Bodnar’s Auction, we use all the necessary tools and resources to find the right home for your memorabilia through consignment. Most of our expert auctioneers have been lifelong collectors — each with great knowledge and skill for determining the value of both vintage and modern toys and comics.
Read More
The Many Benefits of Selling and Buying Toys and Comics at Our Online Auctions
Broader Market Reach
An online auction connects sellers and buyers from around the world, expanding your audience beyond local sales. This exposure often drives up the price, especially for rare items like variant cover comics.
Competitive Pricing Advantage
Bidding creates demand-driven sales, where collectors can get top dollar for prized items such as Action Comics #1 or a pristine Detective Comics issue featuring Batman or Joker.
Specialized Pop Culture Marketplaces
Our online auctions often attract passionate pop culture enthusiasts, increasing the odds of getting your comic book or action figure sold quickly to a knowledgeable buyer.
Transparency and Trust
Bodnar’s Auction’s platform offers detailed listings to help collectors of antique toys or fine art illustrations make confident purchasing decisions.
Convenient and Time-Efficient
Selling online with us avoids the hassle of physical markets. Listing a Superman comic book or Hulk action figure takes minutes, and you can monitor sales from anywhere.
Not sure how valuable your collection is? The professional appraisers at Bodnar’s Auction are available to lend their expertise. While there are multiple factors to consider, you can gain a general understanding of how valuable your vintage or modern collection is by reading below:
Selling or Buying at Our Comic Book Auction
The highest-selling comic book in the world was the 9.0 CGC-graded copy of Action Comics #1, sold for 3.2 million in 2014. Appraising this comic took strategic thought, great attention to detail, and in-depth knowledge. Whether it’s comics or toys, appropriate evaluation is similar:
- Demand and desirability of the comic book
- Rarity and scarcity of your comic
- The comparable cost of your book or collection
- Examination of its condition
Tips to Keep Your Old Comics in Pristine Condition Before Selling
Store in Climate-Controlled Environments
Place your comics in cool, dry locations. This protects them from moisture and UV damage that degrade the paper and art on the pages.
Use Archival-Grade Supplies
Store each comic book in acid-free bags with backing boards to prevent bending and color loss. Collectors of Jack Kirby, John Byrne, and other famed artists appreciate when their works are preserved properly.
Avoid Frequent Handling
Limit contact with collectible issues, as oils and dirt from your hands can harm delicate pages and lower the price.
Keep Your Comics Upright and Unstacked
Position comics vertically in boxes to avoid spine warping. This method is essential for maintaining the condition of high-value issues from DC Comics or Marvel Comics.
Document Provenance and Editions
Keep records of purchase dates and variant cover details if possible, as proper documentation can improve buyer confidence.
Selling or Buying at Our Toy Auction Online
When you sell or buy collectibles at a toy auction, it’s vital to understand how they are valued. Although expert opinions are more accurate, gaining baseline knowledge on how to assess your memorabilia is the perfect motivation to uncover its true value. Before sending your collection to our experts, here’s what you should consider:
- What is the condition of your toy or collection? The more pristine, the higher the value.
- Do you have the original packaging?
- What is the going rate of your memorabilia?
- How rare is your action figure?
Top-Selling Toys at Toy Auctions
Classic Superhero Action Figures
Vintage action figure sets featuring Iron Man, Captain America, and other superheroes can potentially draw competitive bids. These collectibles tap into multi-generational collecting habits.
Moreover, toys from the silver and bronze age eras are always big favorites. Their nostalgic appeal and rarity boost auction appeal. But it’s not just comic book superheroes! Some of our top-selling collectible toys at auction have brought in impressive results. Highlights include a 19th-century Marklin Key Wind Tin Jolanda Boat, which sold for $20,000, and a variety of Clarke gas-powered toy boat outboard motors, ranging from $1,700 to $3,300.
Pop culture collectibles are hot as well, with vintage Star Wars figures still on card or in original boxes generating strong interest—such as a Palitoy ROTJ Boba Fett that sold for $6,200, and an Empire Strikes Back Millennium Falcon in the original box, which brought in $4,600.
Other fan-favorite categories include sealed LEGO sets, Magic: The Gathering cards, Dungeons & Dragons collectibles, Sideshow statues, Hot Toys, and a variety of model trains. These items continue to attract collectors and generate top-dollar bids at auction.
Limited-Edition Action Figures
Rare action figures can sell above market value. Items with packaging intact may possibly gain even more attention, as it’s a sign they’re in good condition.
At Bodnar’s Auction, we hold a range of monthly events that bring in items of all kinds. Whether you are looking for traditional, consignment, or home liquidation auctions, Bodnar’s Auction in NJ has expert auctioneers best to aid you in your sale or purchase. For further inquiries on our online auctions, call us or fill out a contact form today!
Contact Us Today!